There’s nothing better than homemade Apple Pie. Except maybe Salted Maple Caramel Apple Pie.
It’s one of the most wonderful times of year: apple season. The weather is turning crisp, the apple trees are in full bloom, and the pie can be smelled wafting through many a kitchen.
One of my favorite apple picking stories happened during my second year at college in New York City. My friend Sarah and I bought bus tickets from the big apple to apple country (aka the Hudson Valley aka the most beautiful valley I’ve ever been in). We woke up extra early on a Saturday, donned plaid shirts and leather boots, and took a 2 hour trip into the countryside.
All we packed was a huge backpack, a knife, and a jar of crunchy peanut butter.
We made it to the apple orchard and began picking. We were determined to bring as many apples as we could back to our friends in the city.
When we found a particularly delicious tree, we’d sit under it, unscrew our jar of peanut butter, and feast. Then we’d walk for five minutes and do it all over again.
By late afternoon, our bags were packed as full as they could be, so we hopped back on the bus and returned to the city.
Upon stepping out of the bus, the driver said to us “have a good visit in the city!”
Sarah and I turned to one another in our plaid shirts, backpacks, and dirt on our shoes, realizing his assumption of us. We didn’t quite look like city slickers, I guess. Oh well.
Without a doubt, my favorite way to cook with apples is in a pie. Fruity, spiced, and crunchy. Buttery and delicious. It’s just magical.
What makes this particular pie so special is the Salted Maple Caramel filling. It takes 10 minutes, tops, so don’t go skimping because it’s SO worth it. I only used a half recipe for this pie, but I would actually suggest making a full recipe, then drizzling more on top of the pie as you serve it.
In a large bowl, mix together flour, sugar, and salt. Cut butter into small cubes, then work butter into flour mixture using a pastry blender or large forks until it resembles a coarse meal.
Pour in buttermilk and 3 tablespoons vodka, then mix everything together using your hands. Work quickly as to not melt the butter. If dough is too dry, add in another tablespoon of vodka. Form dough into 2 equal sized disks and wrap each with plastic wrap. Place in fridge for at least 1 hour, but up to 2 days.
make the pie
Preheat oven to 375°F. Grease a pie plate with butter.
Over a large work surface, roll out one of your pie disks into a large circle big enough so that it will drape over the edges of your pie plate (i.e. if your pie pan is 9 inches, roll it out to 11 inches). Fit it into pie plate by gently patting it onto the edges of the pan. Place in fridge while you mix the apple filling.
Cut apples into thin strips. Soak them in the lemon juice as you go so they don’t turn brown.
In a large bowl, combine apples, sugar, flour, cinnamon, nutmeg, cloves, salt, and vanilla extract. Remove pie from fridge and layer in apples (try your best to lay them flat– this will help in cooking). If there is any fruit juice in your bowl, don’t pour them in- it will just make your pie soggy.
Roll out second pie disk into a circle big enough so it reaches the edges of the pie pan. Cut dough into various sized strips, the create lattice pattern on top of your prepared filling. To make my pie extra pretty, I weaved two thin strips together and placed them around the edges of the pie.
Brush pie dough with egg wash and sprinkle with turbinado sugar.
Bake for 1 hour, then remove from oven and allow to cool for at least 45 minutes (I know this part is hard, but trust me). Devour!
Leave a comment and rate this recipe!
I was on pie duty this Thanksgiving, and I immediately searched through Broma’s recipes because they never disappoint. I landed on this scrumptious pie! I made this pie one day in advanced, without baking, since we had to travel 2 hours in the car the following day. No problems at all with the quality AND no soggy bottoms! Everyone LOVED the pie! I did cheat and used pre-made pie crust. I was nervous about putting too much of the caramel sauce in the pie since it had to sit 12 hours without baking in the fridge, no issues! We brought the leftover half of the caramel sauce as additional topping to the pie and ice cream. This recipe was so easy to follow, and left no questions. Highly recommend!
So happy you enjoyed this!
Made this last Thanksgiving and it was delicious! Thinking of making it again but was wondering, how much in advance can I make this pie? Would it be okay sitting, wrapped in foil, at room temperature for a day?
Definitely. I’d just recommend popping it back in the oven to heat it up before serving it 🙂
Living in the 1000 islands area of the north country
(think salad dressing yup, that came from north country New York)
I have LOTS of maple products available, I tried the caramel sauce with maple sugar and grade b dark cooking syrup. It came out fantastic, If you don’t like to use white sugar many sugar houses sell products on line and crystalized maple sugar is great in many recipes.
I can’t wait to get the pie made.
Made this over the weekend and it is incredible! And that caramel sauce is likely now a staple of my diet…whoops!
Making this pie now but I don’t see when in the instructions we add the vanilla! Don’t want to leave it out if it’s important! Thanks. 🙂
My apologies! Add them in with the spices. The instructions have been corrected 🙂